Translation note: This article presents a 2023 debate, including the speakers’ opinions and the research figures, technology claims and forecasts cited at that time. It is not an updated review of nuclear technology or a current radiation safety assessment.
Russia’s aggression against Ukraine has created not only a political and security crisis but also an energy crisis. As the war continues and reputational risks grow, many countries formerly dependent on Russian gas have begun abandoning Russian energy resources. Bulgaria, for example, previously relied on Russia for 90% of its gas but switched to supplies from Azerbaijan. Seeking rapid alternatives, more states are announcing plans to restore nuclear capacity or build new units. Nuclear energy, however, has both advantages and drawbacks.
Together with SaveDnipro environmental director Anastasiia Skok and Jan Haverkamp, Greenpeace’s senior nuclear energy and energy policy expert and radiation protection adviser, we explore whether increasing nuclear capacity is a sound response to the energy crisis.
As the US President allocated USD 21 billion in the 2023 budget to nuclear and hydrogen programmes, and Canada issued an SMR action plan, nuclear energy was increasingly discussed as a green source. It is described as the second-largest source of low-carbon electricity. This trend was reinforced in 2022 when the European Parliament recognised gas and nuclear energy within the green taxonomy subject to strict conditions. The original article highlights a requirement concerning accident-tolerant fuel at European nuclear plants by 2025.
Nuclear energy’s revival has been promoted on the basis that operating reactors emit almost no carbon dioxide and fit the European Green Deal’s climate-neutrality policy. Yet emissions cannot be assessed solely during generation: construction requires enormous quantities of concrete and steel, whose production releases CO2, fine particles and other harmful pollutants.
Environmental assessment of any energy source must consider every stage, from extracting raw materials to disposing of or storing waste. Coal-fired electricity, for example, involves not only burning coal but also mining, transport, ash management and reclamation of closed mines, quarries and waste sites.
The same applies to nuclear energy: uranium mining and processing, fuel fabrication and transport, and spent fuel disposal or storage must be included. A University of Sydney study indicatesnuclear greenhouse gas emissions ranging from 10 to 130 grams of CO2 per kilowatt-hour, averaging 65 g/kWh, which the original article compares with wind energy. For comparison, it cites around 900 g/kWh for coal and 450 g/kWh for gas. Construction, maintenance and decommissioning account for around 15–25% of a nuclear plant’s greenhouse gas emissions. Estimates vary widely with factors including the raw materials used and supply chain length.
Uranium use has its own challenges. Mining and processing produce large quantities of tailings: on average, a tonne of ore yields around 1.5 kilograms of uranium. This leaves approximately 998.5 kilograms of waste, stored in heaps or tailings facilities. Mining waste is Ukraine’s largest waste stream. It requires dedicated management, storage, environmental monitoring and treatment.
Spent nuclear fuel remains highly radioactive and contains substances including plutonium, caesium, strontium and iodine. Safe management is essential. The original article describes the absence of a universally accepted approach to recycling or reusing this material and cites a company that submitted a licensing plan for a recycled nuclear fuel facility in 2023. Its US developers claimed their technology could recycle around 95% of spent fuel. The article contrasts this proposal with current storage arrangements, describing storage periods of up to 100 years and the need for a lasting solution.
Countries take different approaches to nuclear waste. EU rules require member states to maintain national policies for spent fuel and radioactive waste management. Progress has been made in safely disposing of very-low- and low-level waste. Finland, France and Sweden had selected deep geological disposal sites for intermediate- and high-level civilian waste. The article anticipated initial repositories opening between 2024 and 2035.
Most nuclear plant types also require large quantities of cooling water. The article cites average use of 75,000 litres per minute for plants with cooling towers and up to 1.9 million litres per minute without them. Plants often have enclosed water bodies with temperatures 5–10 degrees higher and artificial ecosystems. Zaporizhzhia’s cooling pond attracted attention in autumn 2022 after reactor shutdowns lowered its temperature and caused mass fish deaths. Read more in our article.
“It is important to consider not only operating risks and spent fuel disposal or treatment, but also the sector’s resource intensity. Contrary to claims of entirely green nuclear energy promoted by international nuclear lobbyists, the volume of fresh water used in generation has become a major concern. Ukraine already has insufficient fresh water, and locating nuclear plants on its largest waterways complicates the situation,” adds SaveDnipro environmental director Anastasiia Skok.
Jan Haverkamp, Greenpeace’s senior nuclear energy and energy policy expert and radiation protection adviser, also notes: “Nuclear energy is undoubtedly not a circular technology. It has never met any definition of sustainability, and it never will”.
Despite modern safety systems informed by Chornobyl and Fukushima, accident risks remain. The full-scale invasion made this especially urgent when Russian forces entered the Exclusion Zoneand later seized Zaporizhzhia Nuclear Power Plant.
The world and relevant international organisations were wholly unprepared for nuclear plants to become instruments of pressure and wartime blackmail. Russia has occupied and attempted to operate Europe’s largest nuclear plant while also pressuring the international community through attacks on Ukraine’s energy infrastructure. As we wrote previously, nuclear units have limited operational flexibility. If their electricity cannot reach consumers, they may need to shut down. Since the anticipated number of restarts is taken into account at the design stage, such shutdowns affect operational safety.
Jan Haverkamp also commented on nuclear plant safety: “Nuclear Transparency Watch and Greenpeace have proposed that the European Commission and ENSREG learn from Zaporizhzhia to improve the technical protection of all nuclear plants in Europe and beyond against these risks. We believe this should take the form of similar nuclear stress tests. Any nuclear plant may encounter political instability and war during its lifetime. Possible improvements include protection of on-site spent fuel storage, power supply lines and cooling water; independent observers during conflict; better communications for operators and regulators; stronger security measures and safety protocols; and better protection and working conditions for staff. Ideally, independent observers should be present at every plant in future to support safety compliance”.
These drawbacks do not negate nuclear energy’s advantages. Plants can reliably generate large quantities of electricity. Current measured global uranium resources, 6.1 million tonnes, would last approximately 90 years. Nuclear energy could therefore help during the transition from fossil fuels to alternative sources.
In line with global interest in nuclear generation, the IAEA revised its annual projections, estimating nuclear output growth of 12–40% between 2021 and 2030 and 29–250% by 2050. This wide range accounts for possible deployment and mass production of new technologies. Many countries are investing in small modular reactors, which we discussed previously.
Jan Haverkamp comments: “A sensible, rational energy policy should phase out nuclear energy. The necessary upgrades to existing plants and construction of new ones are too expensive. Energy policy should focus on building a 100% renewable electricity system by around 2050. The 2022 energy crisis should also have encouraged stronger energy saving in Europe and faster development of renewables and related infrastructure. Debates about extending ageing nuclear plants’ lives and building new plants distract from urgent climate action, particularly amid the Russian aggression Ukraine faces today”.
The trend towards expanding nuclear capacity therefore rightly prompts debate. Like other energy sources, nuclear plants have advantages and disadvantages that must be discussed openly. They may nevertheless be useful during the transition as humanity moves away from fossil fuels and improves and expands alternative energy infrastructure.
Amid Russian nuclear terrorism, access to background radiation readings matters. At publication, the article reported safe radiation levels in Ukraine. Readings can be checked at any time using our radiation map.
This publication was produced with the support of the European Union. Its contents are the sole responsibility of SaveDnipro NGO and do not necessarily reflect the views of the European Union.