You have probably seen statistics estimating premature deaths from air pollution in Ukraine. According to State Of Global Air 42,900 Ukrainians died in the ‘pre-war’ year 2019 from air pollution by suspended fine particles smaller than 2.5 micrometres, referred to here as PM2.5.
The website also gives deaths from specific diseases associated with PM2.5 pollution. In Ukraine in 2019, it accounted for:
- 7% of deaths from lower respiratory infections;
- 10% of deaths from tracheal, bronchial and lung cancer;
- 9% of deaths from ischaemic heart disease;
- 10% of deaths from ischaemic stroke;
- 10% of deaths from chronic obstructive pulmonary disease;
- 12% of deaths from type 2 diabetes;
- 5% of neonatal deaths, through complications from low birthweight or premature birth and lower respiratory infections.
Respected experts cite these figures. For example, Ukraine’s Public Health Centre at the Ministry of Health refers to them, and we have also seen them in a UNDP report.
What are these estimates based on? Can they be trusted?
State of Global Air itself refers to the Global Burden of Disease study, or GBD, conducted by the Institute for Health Metrics and Evaluation in the United States.
GBD assesses health loss globally from 1990 to the present and is not limited to air quality. It is one of the largest studies quantifying diverse health risk factors, analysing more than 350 causes of health loss. Air pollution is only one.
A publication in The Lancet, one of the most authoritative medical journals, explains important details.
- GBD findings analyse statistical relationships between risk factors and health outcomes, called risk–outcome pairs. Seven pairs have been verified for PM2.5 air pollution. The latest, added in 2020, linked PM2.5 with neonatal deaths from complications associated with low birthweight and premature birth.
- Since 2010, GBD has used World Cancer Research Fund methodology. Its evidence is scrutinised as rigorously as carcinogen research, applying the same strict data verification approaches.
- GBD calculations draw on statistics from previously published studies: it is a meta-analysis. IHME specialists have analysed more than 280,000 scientific sources. The work is enormous; the list of GBD co-authors alone occupies about three densely printed pages.
- Results are continually reviewed and refined. In 2019, for example, systematic reviews were fully updated for 81 risk–outcome pairs. Previously described pairs may eventually be excluded when data requirements tighten or new studies emerge.
- Alongside ambient PM2.5 pollution, GBD identifies adverse health effects from ground-level ozone (O3) and indoor combustion pollution. For Ukraine, these factors are comparatively less significant, with health losses one to two orders of magnitude below those from PM2.5.
Global Burden of Disease is not the only authoritative source quantifying air pollution’s health effects, but it is among the most conservative: its estimates are usually lower than some alternatives. Even these calculations suggest Ukraine prematurely loses the equivalent of a small city of around fifty thousand people each year because of air quality problems — more than 1.5 million premature deaths over the years of independence.
What other studies exist?
European studies use somewhat different methods and examine not only PM2.5 but also NO2. O3 also appears, although these studies repeatedly note that its effects remain insufficiently understood.
For example, European Environment Agencygives these estimates for premature mortality in 2021 across 41 European countries, excluding Ukraine, Belarus and Russia:
- 293,000 deaths associated with exposure to PM2.5 above the WHO guideline of 5 µg/m3.
- 69,000 deaths associated with exposure to NO2above the WHO guideline of 10 µg/m3.
- 27,000 deaths associated with short-term exposure to O3 above 70 µg/m3.
Another example is the report ETC/HE, which combines European health database information to assess air pollution-related disease. Among its three pollutants, it identifies PM2.5 as the most dangerous because of its substantial effects on different disease burden indicators.
Whatever individual studies examine in greater detail, the reality remains troubling: ambient air continues to harm lives and health. Some positive trends exist, but it is too early to speak of major achievements worldwide.
This publication was produced with financial support from the European Union. Its contents are the sole responsibility of SaveDnipro and do not necessarily reflect the views of the European Union.