Civil society urges the Digital Transformation Ministry to protect open data in Ukraine

The Ministry of Digital Transformation has announced public consultation on amendments to Cabinet Resolution No. 835 of 21 October 2015, through a draft resolution amending that act and Resolution No. 867 of 30 November 2016.

Open datasets are currently published according to the principles of openness by default, timeliness, usability, interoperability, continuing applicability and inclusive development.

The Ministry proposes allowing information holders to depart from these principles during a state of emergency or martial law nationwide or in individual regions. They could manually suspend some or all API access to published datasets. In practice, each authority could close information without explanation simply by citing martial law, already in place for six months. 

Since 2011, Ukraine has guaranteed everyone access to public information under a principle of maximum openness. The Law on Access to Public Information requires publication in formats enabling automated electronic processing, free access and reuse for diverse purposes.

At present, no research or analysis has been provided showing that publication of open data harmed Ukrainians’ lives or health.

Resolution No. 835 was adopted in the second year of the Russian–Ukrainian war, with international experts, following an Open Data Readiness Assessment and months of public consultation. Ukraine subsequently improved its Open Data Barometer and Open Data Index rankings. Before 24 February 2022, no registered case linked Russian war crimes against individuals or organisations to information from public state registers. The Defence Ministry likewise had not provided evidence of such a connection. Defence Intelligence instead stated that databases of Ukrainian citizens reached Russian forces through seized administrative buildings or collaborators. The signatories therefore argue that the dataset list in Resolution No. 835 as of 11 February 2022 did not threaten society. The proposed amendments would instead facilitate information closure and could put open data staff at risk of dismissal.

We urge the Ministry to abandon this initiative: it conflicts with public information legislation and threatens open data development. We also call for full access to registers closed after the full-scale invasion on 24 February 2022 and for information holders to publish legally required data important to businesses and the public, including historical datasets and information hidden for moderation reasons.

Signatories:

  1. Anti-Corruption Headquarters
  2. Open Data Association
  3. Technology of Progress
  4. Kharkiv Anti-Corruption Centre
  5. Automaidan
  6. Civil Control Platform
  7. Transparency International Ukraine
  8. DiXi Group
  9. Institute of Legislative Ideas
  10. Power of Truth Centre for Investigative Journalism
  11. On the Edge
  12. Act! Civic Platform
  13. Institute of Analytics and Advocacy
  14. DEJURE Foundation
  15. OpenUp Ukraine community
  16. Ukrainian Network of Integrity and Compliance, UNIC
  17. Centre for Innovations Development
  18. SaveDnipro
  19. Institute for the Development of Social Innovations