Translation note: This article reflects the technology descriptions, cost estimates, development plans and plant conditions reported in January 2023. These are historical projections, not verified current costs, deployment schedules or guarantees of reactor safety.
Against the backdrop of an energy crisis, many countries are deciding to restart or expand nuclear generation. Six main reactor types are used worldwide: pressurised heavy-water reactors, graphite-moderated water-cooled reactors, boiling-water reactors, pressurised-water reactors, gas-cooled reactors and fast breeder reactors. Nuclear energy is developing actively. Here we explore that development and some of the most interesting technologies.
Research and development in nuclear energy aim to address accident risks, difficult waste management and high costs. Scientists are changing reactor operating principles, cooling methods and the ability to use natural uranium or previously used material to generate electricity.
One experimental approach is the thorium molten-salt reactor. Its coolant is based on a mixture of molten salts that can operate at high temperatures and low pressure. These systems also use uranium-233 produced by irradiating thorium-232. Available thorium resources are thought to be around three times greater than uranium-238 resources.
Potential advantages include improved safety. Liquid fuel can support passive protection against overheating: a solid freeze plug melts, allowing fuel to drain. The design also permits continuous removal of gaseous fission products and addition of fresh fuel. Low pressure in the reactor vessel offers another potential safety benefit.
Molten-salt reactors have been known since the 20th century. The original article describes a US experimental reactor programme beginning in the 1950s and a reactor operating for four years. A new attempt to use the technology was announced in summer 2021, when China planned an experimental thorium molten-salt reactor.
Because the reactor does not need fresh water for cooling, it was built in the Gobi Desert. Testing began in autumn, with results eagerly awaited. Despite anticipated safety benefits, high-temperature salts can corrode the reactor and potentially render it unusable. Thorium use also raises nuclear proliferation concerns. If successful, the technology was intended to support commercial reactors entering service by 2030.
Bill Gates’s TerraPower is developing another low-pressure approach: an experimental reactor in Wyoming cooled by liquid sodium. As with the thorium design, low pressure is intended to reduce accident risks.
TerraPower also aims to address nuclear waste. More efficient fuel use was expected to reduce the volume of spent fuel by two-thirds compared with conventional reactors.
The article cites an estimated construction cost of USD 1 billion, below that of conventional nuclear plants. The projected lower cost is attributed to the reactor’s relatively small size and low-pressure operation, reducing the need for exceptionally strong components.
Another widely discussed technology is the small modular reactor, SMR. In 2022, the US President supported USD 21 billion in the 2023 budget for nuclear and hydrogen programmes. Canada also issued its own SMR action plan. Major companies’ interest points to the technology’s potential, with Rolls-Royce, NuScale Power and TerraPower developing designs. According to information from the International Atomic Energy Agency, almost 70 SMR technologies were under development at the time.
SMRs have relatively small outputs, up to 300 MW, compared here with 950 MW for a conventional nuclear unit, and smaller physical dimensions. The article compares a conventional reactor footprint of around 400,000 square metres with 40,000 square metres for an SMR. Modular components can be manufactured in factories and assembled on site. These features are intended to make SMRs cheaper, more transportable and simpler and faster to build.
Small modular reactors generate electricity using the same basic nuclear fission principle as large reactors. In a water-cooled design, a chain reaction in uranium fuel rods heats water in the primary circuit. Heat passes to a secondary steam circuit, and the steam drives a turbine to generate electricity.
Small nuclear power units are not a new idea: they have been used since the 1950s in applications such as icebreakers, aircraft carriers that need to remain at sea for long periods without refuelling, and powerful submarines.
SMRs are presented as nuclear installations with enhanced safety based on inherent and passive protection, using reactor properties and natural processes to support shutdown and cooling in emergencies. Some proposed designs could use natural uranium or spent fuel from other plants. Another important intended capability is flexible operation, increasing generation during the day and reducing it at night to match demand.
Despite declining interest after the major accidents at Chornobyl and Fukushima, the energy crisis has renewed nuclear development. Research currently focuses on making plants safer and cheaper and reducing waste. International interest and investment are particularly strong in small modular reactors promoted as affordable and transportable. Time will show whether the technology becomes widespread and effective.
While experimental technologies are being introduced and tested elsewhere, nine water-water power reactors were operating in Ukrainian-controlled territory at the time of publication, while six more at Zaporizhzhia were under occupation. Hostilities and Russian nuclear terrorism create a persistent risk of a nuclear accident. A quick, accessible way to check reported background radiation readings is our radiation map, updated in real time.