Read the first part here.
This article examines alternatives to dirty coal-fired plants. Replacing them requires other flexible capacity that can rapidly increase output at peak electricity demand and reduce it when the grid does not need power. Part 1 covered gas turbines, gas engines and biomethane. Let us continue.
‘Green’ hydrogen
‘Green’ hydrogen is produced through electrolysis: electricity passes through water to produce hydrogen and oxygen. The electricity must be clean, from wind, solar or nuclear generation, which also has a low carbon footprint. Only such hydrogen can be considered ‘green’.
Notice that so far we are discussing electricity consumption, not generation.
Some projects envisage solar or wind farms devoted entirely to green hydrogen production. They would connect not to the electricity grid but to an electrolyser, itself connected to a gas transmission system capable of carrying hydrogen. Green steelmaking, the green chemical industry and green transport all need it. Simply burning large quantities in a gas turbine for electricity is therefore an extraordinary luxury. Forecasts suggest green hydrogen might match natural gas prices only around 2050.
Hydrogen can also produce electricity without combustion, through fuel cells: small cavities with catalyst-coated walls. The catalyst and membrane enable the reverse of electrolysis. Hydrogen and oxygen from air go in; water, heat and electric current come out, with no harmful emissions.
Fuel cells are already used in hydrogen-powered transport, competing with lithium-ion batteries. If hydrogen infrastructure and cost problems are solved, fuel-cell electric vehicles could become a nightmare for Elon Musk and his battery-powered cars.
Can this technology provide flexible generation?
Technically, yes. Hydrogen fuel cells can be switched on and off by regulating hydrogen supply. The world’s largest hydrogen fuel-cell power plant, Shinincheon Bitdream in Incheon, South Korea, has just 79 MW of capacity and cost USD 300 million. This makes green hydrogen more a technology of the future than a current solution.
Hydropower
Hydropower is traditional in Ukraine, supplying 6.7% of electricity in 2021. Hydroelectric plants have long provided effective system flexibility. Their output can rapidly vary from zero to one hundred per cent, generating less off-peak and increasing quickly at peaks. They can also provide baseload generation.
Pumped storage plants are designed specifically for flexibility. At night, surplus baseload electricity pumps water from a river or lake into an elevated reservoir, often an artificial lake. When the system lacks power, that water flows back down through a generator turbine.
With relatively cheap electricity and no greenhouse gas emissions, this may appear ideal. The question is whether Ukraine can substantially expand it. New river infrastructure floods large areas in our predominantly flat landscape, worsens river water quality and reduces biodiversity.
Recent major Ukrainian hydropower proposals were not implemented following severe criticism from scientists and environmentalists. Experts did not endorse the six-plant Dnister cascade, the Kaniv pumped storage plant or expansion of Tashlyk. The Government’s announced reconstruction of the Kakhovka plant destroyed by Russia also raises many questions. For now, the initiative appears more an attempt to attract and spend financial assistance than a fully justified decision.
The same problems affect small hydropower: building or restoring hundreds of small plants on small rivers. A few hundred megawatts of combined capacity must be weighed against regulating almost every remaining free-flowing river. This runs counter to Europe’s trend towards removing dams. Dam Removal Europe, for example, has removed nearly five thousand barriers in France, Sweden, Finland, Spain, the United Kingdom and other countries.
Hydropower’s potential to add flexible capacity therefore lies largely in modernising existing facilities and is not particularly great. Climate change also reduces river flows, diminishing hydropower potential year by year. Green hydrogen production needs water too, potentially reducing flows further.
Modular nuclear power plants
Nuclear power generally provides baseload, not flexible generation. The units Ukraine plans to build with US company Westinghouse would, however, allow safe load-following within a 30–40% capacity range. Some flexibility is therefore emerging even in large reactors, but new large reactors cannot be built quickly.
Small modular reactors (SMRs) appear more promising here. This new technology is developing rapidly. SMRs have relatively low capacities of 100–300 MW and smaller industrial sites of around 40,000 m2. By comparison, standard Ukrainian nuclear units have 1,000 MW capacity, while a conventional reactor occupies about 400,000 m2.
SMRs consist of modules manufactured in factories and installed at the plant site. For this article, their most important feature is high flexibility.
Their main drawback is being a completely new technology not yet sufficiently proven worldwide. Real advantages and drawbacks can only be judged from practical experience. Perhaps this explains leading developers’ interest in projects in Ukraine: why not test a new technology in a country compelled to seek new solutions now?
Media have reported promising combinations of SMRs and electrolysers for green hydrogen. We are more interested in possible integration with coal plants. Existing coal sites already have infrastructure that could simplify conversion for SMRs, reducing capital investment and construction costs.
DTEK reportedly held preliminary talks with Rolls-Royce about installing SMRs at its thermal plant sites. The parties would examine converting up to eight existing coal sites. We find the prospect of DTEK becoming a nuclear operator somewhat imprudent. Its thermal plants’ technical condition has never been exemplary, and even a quarter of the environmental improvements promised during privatisation were not delivered. Can such a company be entrusted with nuclear facilities?
A final thought
There is no ideal solution to flexible generation. A sensible mix of these methods and technologies may be needed. Part of the flexibility challenge can also be addressed without adding generation: energy storage has balancing potential, as do solutions in system management. We will explore these in future publications.
This publication was produced with financial support from the European Union through the EMITTER project. Its contents are the sole responsibility of SaveDnipro and do not necessarily reflect the views of the European Union.