Environmental crimes during war: discussion highlights

Translation note: These are statements and assessments made during the discussion on 29 March 2022, not a current situation report. Claims attributed to speakers, including alleged deliberate attacks, are reproduced as their statements at that time.

On 29 March 2022, Ecoaction and the Commission on Journalism Ethics held an online discussion on environmental crimes during war. SaveDnipro head Iryna Chernysh took part.

Here are the main points raised during the discussion.

Iryna Chernysh, head of SaveDnipro:

• SaveDnipro, working with Ukraine’s Ministry of Environmental Protection and Natural Resources and other data holders, has begun publishing current readings on a shared radiation map of Ukraine https://www.saveecobot.com/radiation-maps. Specialists collect readings automatically or manually every day, even in the most dangerous settlements. At the time, the map included 514 measurement points: 453 public-sector points and 61 community or other sources. Readings from the nuclear plants themselves and the Chornobyl Exclusion Zone were unavailable, although nearby areas were covered.

• SaveEcoBot also provides a fire map https://www.saveecobot.com/fire-maps, showing wind direction and satellite fire detections across Ukraine over the previous 24 hours, including in the Chornobyl Exclusion Zone, using NASA data.

• A new fire statistics page is available in SaveEcoBot’s analytics section https://www.saveecobot.com/analytics/fires. It shows detections for Ukraine, individual regions and the Exclusion Zone, and trends over the previous month.

• russia is acting like a terrorist, deliberately creating threats to Ukrainians and the wider world.

Roman Shakhmatenko, Deputy Environment Minister for European Integration

• We have established tools to collect information on war crimes that damage the environment. Based on this information, we will prepare cases for the International Court of Justice and the International Criminal Court.

• We are developing methods to assess damage to ecosystem services and seek compensation from the aggressor.

Yevheniia Zasiadko, head of climate at Ecoaction

• Using open sources, we have recorded 111 examples of environmental crimes. The largest group involves damage to industrial facilities (43); others concern energy security, marine and other ecosystems, livestock waste and nuclear safety.

• Damage to a high-voltage electricity network led to flooding at the Zolote mine in Luhansk region. Hostilities have damaged combined heat and power plants and thermal power stations in Chernihiv, Luhansk and Trypillia. The Okhtyrka plant has been completely destroyed.

• The greatest risk for Ukraine and the world is nuclear. Fighting has directly affected the Chornobyl and Zaporizhzhia nuclear power plants and Kharkiv’s Neutron Source facility, which has faced repeated russian shelling.

What should be done? One first step is for the world to abandon fossil fuels, whose revenues help finance russia’s war.

Oleksii Vasyliuk, head of the Ukrainian Nature Conservation Group

• The situation is especially severe around Irpin, Bucha and nearby towns towards Chornobyl, where forests are burning.

• There are reports that occupying forces deliberately shelled Chornobyl forests when the wind was blowing towards Kyiv to worsen radiation conditions. Although the occupation of Chornobyl and Zaporizhzhia had not yet caused a catastrophe, these actions were already affecting people. This is nuclear terrorism. Damage to ammonia tanks in Sumy region is another example: limited economic damage can have consequences for people comparable to chemical weapons.

• russian forces are deliberately taking actions that worsen the environment and people’s living conditions.

• Around 44% of protected territory is now in areas of fighting or humanitarian disaster.

• Record every detail so that the full environmental damage can be assessed after the war.

• Most importantly, there will be a future, and nature will recover.

A recording of the discussion is available at: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lfJKp7ljTZc