Translation note: This article reflects the legal debate and damage estimates reported in January 2023. Ecocide was not a standalone crime in the Rome Statute described here; Article 8 addresses certain environmental harm as a war crime. The original article’s expectations about future amendments and compensation are advocacy, not a guarantee of jurisdiction, retroactive application or an award of reparations. Sources: Rome Statute: jurisdiction and war crimes.
Hostilities cause irreparable harm to Ukraine’s environment, bringing ecocide increasingly into discussions at international forums. Here we explore how international and Ukrainian law understand ecocide and what is needed to obtain compensation from Russia.
During his address to the G20 summit, President Volodymyr Zelenskyy presented Ukraine’s ten-point Peace Formula, including the need to protect nature immediately and stop ecocide. The European Commission also statedthat Russia must pay Ukraine reparations for ecocide and called for continued documentation of Russian environmental crimes. But is recognising environmental harm as ecocide straightforward?
The term ecocide has been widely used since the 1970s. It is a criminal offence in Ukrainian law and the subject of international criminalisation proposals. In its broadest sense, it means harm to Earth’s systems — the biosphere, lithosphere, hydrosphere and others — causing substantial structural changes and other severe consequences. Its most destructive form is wartime ecocide, where environmental harm is inflicted for military or political purposes.
People have used environmental destruction as a weapon throughout history. In the fourth century BC, the Greeks poisoned the River Pleistos during the siege of Kirrha, causing mass deaths among the city’s defenders and aquatic life. During the Vietnam War, US aircraft sprayed more than 100,000 tonnes of defoliants over Cambodia and Vietnam. The original article reports that nearly half of Vietnam’s arable land became unsuitable for farming, two million hectares of forest were destroyed and two-thirds of biological species disappeared.
Russian forces now harm Ukraine’s environment both deliberately, for military or political purposes, and indirectly. According to estimates by the State Environmental Inspectorate, 11 months of war caused more than UAH 1.743 trillion in environmental damage: over UAH 688 billion from soil contamination and littering of land, UAH 998 billion from air pollution, and more than UAH 56 million from pollution and littering of water resources. The article also cites more than six million farm animal deaths and around 50,000 dolphin deaths.
Ukrainian criminal law defines ecocide as the mass destruction of flora or fauna, poisoning of the atmosphere or water resources, or other acts capable of causing an environmental disaster. Under Article 441 of the Criminal Code , it is a particularly serious offence punishable by eight to fifteen years’ imprisonment.
Despite the existence of this offence, only in 2022 did the Prosecutor General’s Office first announce a suspicion of ecocide in Ukraine’s history. The main basis was State Environmental Inspectorate oversight conducted between 2015 and 2022. Specialists needed seven years to assemble evidence of river pollution causing irreversible ecosystem changes.
The Ukrainian offence contains evaluative concepts not explained by the Criminal Code or Supreme Court legal positions, making classification of specific environmental harm as ecocide difficult. Terms such as mass destruction of flora or fauna and poisoning of the atmosphere or water resources remain undefined. There are no established quantitative and qualitative legal criteria for determining ecosystem destruction, including duration, affected area and amount of damage.
The subjective element of ecocide involves intent, often direct intent. The offence is considered complete when an act listed in Article 441 capable of causing an environmental disaster is committed. Proving ecocide requires establishing both the act itself and the real danger of an environmental disaster resulting from it.
As reported by Environment–People–Law, as of June 2022 Ukraine had no convictions under the ecocide article. The first announced suspicion is therefore significant: a conviction could establish a practice of detecting and punishing ecocide.
At the time of this article, there was no equivalent standalone offence in European legislation. International efforts were still focused on recognising ecocide as a separate crime and adding it to the Rome Statute.
At present, Article 5 of the Rome Statute lists four categories: genocide, crimes against humanity, war crimes and aggression. Certain environmental harm falls within war crimes, but the wording in Article 8is difficult to apply and prove in court, as discussed in the original account. Serious environmental harm in peacetime is not itself listed as a standalone crime in the Statute.
The Stop Ecocide Foundation and Sweden’s Parliament were working on amendments. The initiative began in 2020, marking 75 years since the opening of the Nuremberg trials for German war crimes during the Second World War.
Experts propose amending the Statute’s preamble to recognise that serious environmental destruction and deterioration threaten humanity and the world. They also propose adding ecocide to Article 5 and a separate article defining its elements.
The proposed definition describes ecocide as unlawful or wanton acts committed with knowledge of a substantial likelihood of severe and either widespread or long-term environmental damage. Proposed definitions explain wanton conduct as reckless disregard for damage clearly excessive relative to anticipated social and economic benefits; severe damage as very serious adverse changes, disruption or harm to any environmental element, including human life or natural, cultural and economic resources; widespread damage as extending beyond a limited area, crossing borders or affecting entire ecosystems, species or large populations; long-term damage as irreversible or not remediable through natural recovery within a reasonable period; and the environment as Earth, its biosphere, cryosphere, lithosphere, hydrosphere and atmosphere, as well as outer space.
An important step towards clearer recognition of ecocide was the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe’s adoption of a resolution on the environmental impact of war on 25 January 2023. Members emphasised defining ecocide in both national and international law. The resolution recognised the need to amend the Rome Statute and add ecocide as a new crime. The original article presents this as a potential avenue for Ukraine to seek accountability for destroyed ecosystems, contaminated soils, burned forests and other environmental damage.
There is already a precedent for requiring an aggressor to compensate environmental harm. In spring 1991, the UN Compensation Commission was established to examine claims arising from Iraq’s invasion and occupation of Kuwait. Environmental claims totalled USD 80 billion. The Commission partially upheld them, awarding just over USD 5 billion.
Ecocide has become widely recognised in public debate alongside crimes against humanity and other unlawful acts. Discussions in Ukraine and internationally continue about reparations for Russia’s environmental damage. The original article expresses hope that amendments to the Rome Statute could support accountability and full compensation, while the actual legal avenues and requirements remain to be established. We must continue carefully documenting Russian war crimes.
If you witness a Russian crime against the environment, you can document it. Open @SaveEcoBot in Telegram or Viber and follow the steps. All reports are — anonymised and confidential and are sent to the Environment Ministry’s operational headquarters to support claims before the International Court of Justice for compensation from the aggressor country.