Environmental organisations oppose restrictions on environmental rights

Environmental organisations oppose restrictions on environmental rights

Representatives of the environmental movement call on the Government, Ukraine’s Ministry of Environmental Protection and Natural Resources, and members of Parliament’s Committee on Environmental Policy and Nature Management to reconsider proposals that conflict with European integration and ensure sustained, progressive expansion of public participation in environmental decision-making.

On 1 February 2023, under number 8410 , the Government registered a bill in the Verkhovna Rada to amend Ukraine’s Law on Environmental Impact Assessment.

Alongside several appropriate innovations, the bill substantially restricts opportunities for public participation in EIA, causing serious concern among civil society representatives.

  1. Shorter public consultation periods

The bill proposes reducing consultation on a notice of planned activity from 20 to 12 working days. This is difficult to accept. Having introduced public participation at the EIA report’s scoping stage, the state must allow adequate time for meaningful engagement. A commonly recognised international benchmark is at least one calendar month.

The upper limit for consultation on planned activity after submission of the EIA report would also be reduced. It would last exactly 25 working days, with neither the business nor the authorised body permitted to extend it even when necessary. This weakens Aarhus rights, contrary to the Convention’s direction. Democratic rights should develop towards broader public access and opportunities.

  1. Changes to public notification methods in EIA

The requirement to publish notices and announcements in print media would be abolished. Instead, businesses would have to display these documents in at least three public places in the area of the planned activity and all settlements potentially affected. Such places include noticeboards at local government buildings, social and cultural facilities, post offices, permanent public transport stops, designated locations provided by public authorities or local government, and other places where people gather. 

Time and practice will show whether these changes improve public awareness. Print publication can still be effective in some cases. It is no coincidence that this notification method appears in the recently adopted Law on Administrative Procedure, due to enter into force in December this year. We believe print publication should remain in the law, at least as an option for businesses.

  1. Changes to access to EIA reports

As before, in addition to the register, physical copies of EIA reports and other information submitted by businesses would remain available throughout consultation in publicly accessible locations at the authorised body, local government offices in potentially affected communities, and the business’s premises.

However, the provision previously making businesses responsible for producing paper copies would now be conditional on a public request.

“9. The business shall ensure production of copies of the environmental impact assessment report and other documentation it supplies that is necessary for EIA, for physical placement for public inspection under paragraphs five and six of this Article, where requested by the public.”»

This is a deeply flawed proposal. What request is meant? Can a person ask to inspect the report and receive a copy immediately, or must they request that a copy be produced for later inspection? Should the request go to the relevant public authority or the business? How quickly must it be processed? In practice, these uncertainties will lead to conflicting interpretations, inconsistent enforcement and violations of public rights.

Moreover, the provision conflicts with Article 7(6) of the EIA Law, which states that consultation after submission of the EIA report begins on the date the announcement is officially published and the public is given access to inspect the EIA report. In other words, consultation legally begins only when paper reports are available at the authorised body, relevant local government offices and the business’s premises. How a request fits into this process is unclear. It would appear that until someone requests a copy, consultation cannot begin and the entire EIA procedure is suspended. Given that shortening EIA is one objective of bill No. 8410, this proposal is particularly inappropriate.

The change appears motivated by the Ministry’s wish to digitise EIA completely and remove paper documents. Yet even in the digital age, not all Ukrainians use digital technologies, and everyone must have equal opportunities to participate. Digitisation should improve access, not restrict it by leaving remote areas, rural communities and older generations behind. If businesses no longer submit paper documentation to the authorised body, previously also used for public inspection, they must still be required to provide one paper copy of the EIA report and other necessary documentation for public inspection at the authority’s premises. Otherwise, it is unclear how the authority can fulfil its obligations under Article 4(5) and (6) of the EIA Law.

New conditions for public hearings

Another unwelcome surprise is a new condition for holding hearings. The public consultation article would require at least ten people to register before a hearing is held. If fewer than ten register, no hearing would be scheduled.

This clearly does not support the effective public participation required by Article 6 of the Aarhus Convention. Hearings enable ordinary people to participate, including those who find written comments difficult but have something to say about planned activity or local environmental conditions. Requiring registration by ten local residents, perhaps encountering EIA for the first time, is excessive and unrealistic. In our view, even one person’s advance registration is sufficient evidence of public interest to justify scheduling a hearing.

Representatives of the environmental movement call on the Ministry, Government and members of Parliament to reconsider these positions: European integration in environmental matters is directly connected with sustained, progressive expansion of public opportunities to participate in environmental decision-making.

Environment–People–Law International Charitable Organisation

Ukrainian Nature Conservation Group NGO

Ecopark Osokorky NGO

Black Sea Women’s Club NGO

Volterra NGO

Olena Pelykh, lawyer

ANTS National Interests Advocacy Network NGO

Oleksii Burkovskyi, Donetsk Regional Organisation of the All-Ukrainian Environmental League

Zero Waste Society NGO

Mariupol Zero Waste initiative group

Zero Waste Lutsk NGO

National Ecological Centre of Ukraine

World Wide Fund for Nature Ukraine, WWF-Ukraine

Green World Environmental and Humanitarian Association NGO

Danube–Carpathian Programme NGO

Institute of Econology NGO

Black Sea Branch of the Ukrainian Ecological Academy of Sciences

Nataliia Bihun, Clean Planet initiative

Olha Zhelezko, Clean Planet initiative

MART NGO

Serhii Fedorynchyk, Head of the Information Centre of the Green World Ukrainian Environmental Association, 1992 Statute

M. Yu. Mykhalko, Union for the Rescue of Holosiiv NGO

SaveDnipro NGO

All-Ukrainian Environmental Association Green World NGO

Pechenihy Environmental Group NGO

Regional Council of Entrepreneurs, Kharkiv regional NGO

Green Movement of Mykolaiv Region NGO

Budmo! regional newspaper

Green Dossier International Charitable Information Centre

Kremenchuk Nature Conservation Society NGO

Energy of Peace, Kharkiv city NGO

BAKHMAT NGO

Ilyess El Kortbi, Ukrainian spokesperson in the international Fridays For Future movement

Mila Sirychenko, activist in the international Fridays For Future movement

Krai Environmental Club NGO

Eremurus Environmental Club NGO

City of the Sun Civic Initiative NGO

 Etalon Civic Centre NGO

Centre for International Cooperation and Project Implementation NGO

Forest Initiatives and Society NGO

Tetiana Hodovska, researcher and activist

Talne District Green World environmental NGO

Our Home Maniava Youth Environmental NGO

Energy of Peace Kharkiv City Youth Environmental NGO

Horizon-17 NGO

Centre for Environmental Initiatives Ecoaction NGO

SICH Human Rights Group NGO

Ukrainian Environmental Club Green Wave NGO