Without an official parliamentary Environment Committee decision or Environment Ministry position, and in violation of parliamentary procedure, MPs have adopted a bill abolishing strategic environmental assessment, SEA, for recovery programmes, including those for regions and local communities. This could worsen long-term environmental conditions in settlements destroyed by Russia and cost Ukraine reconstruction investment.
It could also weaken Ukraine’s position as the European Parliament considers accelerating its EU membership application, because strategic environmental assessment is required under the EU–Ukraine Association Agreement.
What happened?
In just one month, MPs partially reversed the results of 15 years of work by experts and international partners on strategic environmental assessment.
They adopted bill No. 7282 on priority urban development reforms, stating that comprehensive recovery programmes for regions and community territories are not subject to SEA, under Article 15-2(8). The bill was sent to the President for signature on 13 May 2022.
IMPORTANT: The bill was considered by committees including Economic Development, EU Integration and Anti-Corruption Policy.
Do Dmytro Natalukha, Ivanna Klympush-Tsintsadze and Anastasiia Radina really support rolling back environmental reforms that civil society fought for over 15 years?
What comes next: abolishing EIA? We would welcome the views of Ruslan Stefanchuk and Olha Stefanishyna.
The bill was not considered by the parliamentary Environment Committee, so no opinion from it exists. Nor is there an official position from the Environment Ministry or Minister Ruslan Strilets. We ask them to respond and explain to the President why bill No. 7282 must not be signed, given Ukraine’s declared green recovery and European integration commitments.
Why does this matter?
SEA:
- takes place before plans and programmes are implemented and helps prevent harm to the environment and health;
- allows public participation in drafting plans and programmes through consultation;
- enables authorities to prevent environmental and health risks and consider alternatives consistent with sustainable development.
These safeguards are crucial when Russian aggression has destroyed cities, caused drinking water shortages, disabled sewerage and produced substantial pollution.
Before SEA existed in Ukraine, the country experienced terrible environmental disasters, including the Hrybovychi landfill fire, recurring accidents at Burshtyn Thermal Power Plant and the hexachlorobenzene crisis in Kalush. Civil society spent years fighting for SEA to help prevent such situations. The law finally entered into force in 2018, a step towards EU alignment.
Without consulting all stakeholders, MPs rapidly removed a key procedure for assessing programmes’ environmental consequences, depriving communities of the chance to consider alternatives that respect people and the environment.
Parliament’s Main Legal Department warned that removing SEA could mean development impacts on citizens’ lives and health are overlooked and narrow the right to a safe environment guaranteed by Article 50(1) of the Constitution.
Why SEA matters during war and reconstruction
The SEA report should assess whether post-war conditions allow particular developments and how new infrastructure would affect residents’ health. It includes consultation with environmental and health authorities, which can advise on reducing impacts during regional recovery, waste infrastructure development, water supply and sewerage reconstruction, and use of mined or contaminated land. Bypassing SEA could therefore prove costly for communities, investors, local authorities, the environment and our children.
Abandoning SEA: international risks
The reconstruction initiative described as a Marshall Plan for Ukraine is being developed with civil society experts, the EU and G7 countries and could potentially mobilise trillions of euros. Access depends on declaring and implementing European integration commitments in legislation. This ill-considered step could complicate access to international reconstruction assistance, especially while Ukraine’s EU application is under consideration.
On 5 May, more than 50 Ukrainian civil society organisations supported green post-war recovery and European environmental standards, including SEA.
On 11 May, the UN Global Compact, a major business network supporting the Sustainable Development Goals with over 100 Ukrainian and 12,000 global participants, published green recovery proposals for MPs, the Cabinet and international partners. They also supported environmental oversight reform, SEA and EIA.
Ukrainian version: https://bit.ly/3luIaFB
In view of the above, we ask:
1. The President to return bill No. 7282 to Parliament with proposals rather than sign it.
2. That the public be informed of the decisions taken.
Yours sincerely,
Environment–People–Law International Charitable Organisation
Ekoltava NGO
Ukrainian Climate Network
National Ecological Centre of Ukraine
Danube–Carpathian Programme
SaveDnipro NGO / SaveEcoBot
Centre for Environmental Initiatives Ecoaction NGO
Ukrainian Nature Conservation Group NGO
EcoPravo-Kharkiv civic organisation
Green Dossier International Charitable Information Centre
Ecosphere NGO
Bureau of Environmental Investigations NGO
Ecoclub NGO
Ecopark Osokorky NGO
Stop Poisoning Kryvyi Rih civic union