Translation note: This page reproduces the English appeal already included in the original March 2023 publication, including its original figures and signatories. The original Ukrainian version is available through the language switcher.
To:
Executive Vice President of the European Commission
Frans Timmermans
European Commissioner for Energy
Kadri Simons
European Commissioner for Environment
Virginijus Sinkevičius
Joint appeal of civil society organizations
Having read the Memorandum of Understanding between the European Union and Ukraine regarding the strategic partnership on biomethane, hydrogen and other synthetic gasses, which the parties signed in the run up to the Ukraine-EU summit, as well as taking into account Ukraine’s earlier commitments in the fields of energy sector reform and climate policy, decarbonization of the economy, as well as Ukraine’s participation in the international initiative “Global Methane Pledge”, we consider it necessary to draw your attention to a number of unresolved issues of high priority in Ukraine that require EU assistance for implementation of comprehensive and sustainable solutions.
As an expert-analytical study conducted in 2021 showed, there is practically no comprehensive public policy in Ukraine regarding proper accounting for and reduction of methane emissions, as well as lack of verification of reported data on methane emissions.[1] Provisions for adequate taxation of methane emissions also require significant improvements.
This problem was recognized at the state level, and in December 2021, at the UN climate conference COP26 in Glasgow, Ukraine joined the “Global Methane Pledge” initiative launched by the EU and the U.S., which provides for the joint action of governments to reduce global methane emissions by at least 30% by 2030 relative to the level of 2020.
We must emphasize that today, in the conditions of full-scale armed aggression of the Russian Federation, measures to monitor and reduce methane leaks in Ukraine are doubly relevant for our country. Individual measures, such as installation of automated electronic protection valves, contribute to increasing the resistance of gas infrastructure to enemy attacks. Along with this, the capture and utilization of coal mine methane, as well as biogas at landfills, are additional sources of energy resources and can contribute to improving energy security.
We are also concerned that in the absence of proper monitoring and accounting of methane leaks at the production stage, which is currently not regulated in Ukraine, significant and unaccounted emissions of methane into the atmosphere could be prevented once compliance is ensured with modern industry standards and the upcoming new EU Methane Regulation.
We welcome the initial steps taken to solve the above-mentioned problems, in particular, Ukraine and several companies show dedication to follow the EU policies and global initiatives. In particular, Ukraine joined the Global Methane Pledge, and some companies are partners in the OGMP 2.0 with commitments to improve methane emission measurements and reduction.
According to the draft National Inventory Report of Anthropogenic Emissions from Sources and Removals of Greenhouse Gases in Ukraine for 1990-2020, in the last reported year, the most significant source of methane emissions was the energy sector – 66%. The largest share of methane emissions in the energy sector comes from oil & gas sector (production, transportation, storage, distribution, and consumption), followed by coal mines.
Massive potential exists in Ukraine to curb existing and prevent future methane emissions with well-known technical measures. Moreover, there is a discrepancy in the data between the reports of the State Statistics Service of Ukraine and the National Inventory Report of Greenhouse Gas Emissions due to different methodologies, which will require coordination and synchronization in the future – at least to reduce the level of uncertainty. Further, estimation methodologies as prescribed by OGMP 2.0 and Marcogaz reporting templates, started to be used by the industry, have to be taken into account. As of now, there is no specific piece of legislation in Ukraine defining rules for the accurate measurement, reporting and verification of methane emissions in the energy sector, as well as the abatement of those emissions.
According to corporate reporting of NJSC Naftogaz of Ukraine,[2] Its overall methane emissions have amounted to almost 443 thousand tonnes CO2eq, and its subsidiary Ukrgazvydobuvannia JSC is responsible for 60% of all GHG emissions.
Given the fact that state-owned enterprises – Naftogaz group and Gas TSO of Ukraine LLC (GTSOU) – are key stakeholders in the development of the national policy to reduce methane emissions, as well as develop industry standards, their role is instrumental in planning and implementation of necessary measures and implementation of industry reforms, in particular regarding supporting the government in development and approval of the necessary regulatory and legal basis, and harmonization of state standards with international best practice. It is also extremely important to implement an end-to-end system for full methane emissions accounting following international standards and practices, as well as leak detection and repair (LDAR) standards. With this in mind, we ask you to consider the possibility of providing appropriate technical assistance and conducting training/twinning for Ukrainian specialists in close coordination with other donors.
In this context, we call on the Commission to intensify the policy dialogue and provide additional assistance for implementation of measures to reduce methane emissions in Ukraine, which are capable of turning the environmental problems into solutions for improving the country’s energy security. Given that investments in the elimination of methane leaks in the energy sector are providing return by reductions in losses, they represent low hanging fruit for improving the energy security of the state, environmental and economic indicators of system operators and businesses. The EU as the key partner in rebuilding Ukraine has appropriate means and solutions to help solve this task.
We welcome the fact that on December 19, 2022, as part of the work on the “Gas and Hydrogen Package” legislation, the Council supported the proposal of a new Methane Regulation, which is set to establish strict and obligate standards for the detection, accounting and elimination of methane emissions and leaks in the oil and gas industry. We hope for a swift adoption of this legislation and its timely implementation.
Please inform the signatories of this appeal about current and planned EU programs to support measures in the field of eliminating methane leaks and the implementation of other measures aimed at achieving the goals of the Global Methane Pledge, existing professional training opportunities, as well as about the state of the bilateral dialogue between Ukraine and the EU regarding the policy of reducing methane emissions in all sectors.
We look forward to the Commission’s clarifications on the specified issues and hope for open and constructive dialogue with civil society.
Thankful for your ongoing support to Ukraine, undersigned representatives of Ukrainian civil society:
Razom We Stand
Center for environmental initiatives Ecoaction
NGO Save Dnipro
DiXi Group
Energy Transition Coalition
Solar Energy Association of Ukraine
Danube-Carpathian Programme
NGO Ekoltava
NGO Zero Waste Lviv
NGO Zero Waste Lutsk
NGO Zero Waste Society
NGO Center for international cooperation and project implementation
NGO Social Initiative”City of the Sun”
NGO Ecoclub
Greenpeace Central and Eastern Europe
[1] https://dixigroup.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/09/dixi_group_methane_policy_brief.pdf