Greenwashing: how companies manipulate environmental claims

Greenwashing: how companies manipulate environmental claims

Translation note: This translation of a March 2023 article clarifies its cosmetic-ingredient advice. Ingredient names alone do not establish that a product is unsafe or contains regulated microplastics, and finding parabens in tumour samples does not show that they cause breast cancer. Historical examples below describe the original article’s criticism of company campaigns. Sources: National Cancer Institute: parabens and breast cancer; European Commission: microplastics restriction.

Climate change and environmental degradation are prompting more people to take an interest in environmental protection and greener lifestyles. Consumers increasingly consider the environmental impact of what they buy. Businesses and corporations have responded, sometimes by exploiting that concern through greenwashing. What does this mean, and how can we avoid being misled?

Greenwashing, a term combining greenwashingwith the idea of whitewash — whitewashing — is a marketing technique that presents a product or brand as more natural or environmentally responsible than it really is. It helps maintain a green corporate image, gain political or social support and increase sales. The term emerged in 1986, although the methods were already used in the 1960s.

Historical examples illustrate the problem. In the early 1970s, Keep America Beautiful released a public service advertisement showing a Native American character crying at the sight of littered land. Its message was that people cause pollution and can stop it. The idea sounds reasonable, but several disposable beverage packaging companies, including Coca-Cola, initiated and financed the campaign. In the article’s criticism, they shifted responsibility to consumers while continuing to produce and sell enormous quantities of single-use packaging.

The article also criticises Shell’s attempts to present itself as environmentally responsible, citing a website image of Australia’s Great Barrier Reef accompanied by a claim about caring for biodiversity. Shell explores, extracts, refines, transports and sells oil and natural gas, activities with substantial environmental impacts and accident risks. The article points to the 15 January 1999 oil spill, described as the largest freshwater spill, as an example behind its criticism.

Ukrainian corporations use greenwashing too. In 2019, Myronivskyi Hliboproduct, owner of the Nasha Riaba and Bashchynskyi brands, worked with media on a series of environmental materials. At the same time, MHP had repeatedly faced environmental controversies involving unauthorised mass burial of poultry carcasses and soil contamination, production waste discharged into rivers, and high-capacity water wells for industrial needs. Against that background, the article views its campaign about grassroots environmental initiatives as an attempt to improve its green image after scandals.

Greenwashing extends far beyond large corporations. Environmental considerations increasingly influence consumer choices: the article cites an average of around 55% of buyers willing to pay more when producers consider their effects on society and the environment. Common examples include vague terms and prefixes such as environmentally friendly, eco, bio and natural, a leaf in a logo, or green branding.

How can you avoid everyday greenwashing? Read ingredients, examine packaging and verify certification. Above all, recognise that no product has absolutely no environmental impact.

The original article singles out several cosmetic ingredient categories: Quaternium and Polyquaternium polymers; PEG and PPG compounds; preservatives such as methylparaben, ethylparaben, propylparaben and butylparaben; silicones such as dimethicone, cyclomethicone and names ending in -siloxane or -conol; and paraffin or mineral oil. It raises concerns about persistence, petroleum-based origins and health effects. These names alone, however, are not a sound basis for declaring all such ingredients harmful or all polymers microplastics. In particular, the presence of parabens in breast tumour samples does not establish that they cause cancer. Assess substantiated product claims, certification and evidence rather than relying on a blanket blacklist.

Look for verifiable certification standards, such as Ecocert, ICEA Eco Bio Cosmetic, BDIH, Cosmébio, COSMOS and NSF. The EU organic leaf logo may also appear, accompanied by information on the control body and the origin of agricultural raw materials. Check what a particular label actually certifies rather than assuming all green logos mean the same thing.

The article notes that Ukraine regulates the term organic and that only certified products may use it. Certification is reflected in an official label, introduced on 1 August 2019, rather than merely a product name. Producers undergo annual certification checks. Certification and licensing costs may affect prices. Certificates can be verified on the ioas.org website and in the register of the Ministry of Agrarian Policy. 

Choose packaging that can actually be recycled where you live, such as glass, metal and appropriately certified cardboard. FSC certification concerns responsible forest sourcing, rather than guaranteeing local recycling. Take particular care with plastic packaging, since not all types are collected or recycled, especially during wartime.

The examples above show that companies can greenwash through public relations as well as products. We often hear that a business has joined a clean-up, planted trees or created green offices. These actions can genuinely help the environment, but they must be assessed alongside its main business. For example, a large energy company operating thermal power plants may announce plans to plant thousands of trees. That is welcome, but it amounts to greenwashing if the company does not modernise its power plants’ filtration systems.

Greenwashing is a marketing technique used by unscrupulous businesses to attract consumers and whitewash their reputations. It is unlikely to disappear soon. We must learn to distinguish these products and businesses from genuinely responsible producers. This is not easy, but we can learn and gradually build the habit of supporting those who truly care about nature and the future. 

Do you share our values and want to support the team? Make a contribution! Your support will help us continue expanding radiation and air quality monitoring, fighting for open and digitised environmental data, and pursuing other ambitious goals.