Civil society open letter opposing the exclusion of industrial parks from environmental impact assessment

Civil society open letter opposing the exclusion of industrial parks from environmental impact assessment
Photo by Devon Rogers on Unsplash

Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine Committee on Economic Development

Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine Committee on Environmental Policy and Nature Management

Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine Committee on Ukraine’s Integration into the European Union

On 11 February 2025, the Verkhovna Rada adopted at first reading Draft Law No. 12117 on amendments to certain legislative acts to improve industrial park operations. Among other measures, it proposes excluding industrial parks from Ukraine’s Law ‘On Environmental Impact Assessment’ (the EIA Law) and abolishing the EIA requirement for such infrastructure projects. The bill’s sponsors consider EIA an excessive regulatory barrier to attracting investment to Ukraine.

Environment-People-Law (EPL) strongly disagrees and calls on civil society organisations to join this open letter. The activities listed in the EIA Law are intended to transpose the corresponding categories in Annexes I and II to Directive 2011/92/EU on the assessment of the effects of certain public and private projects on the environment (the EIA Directive). EIA for industrial parks implements the category ‘industrial estate development projects’ in point 10(a) of Annex II. Assessing such projects is normal practice in EU countries with industrial parks and cannot be regarded as an unnecessary regulatory barrier. Excluding industrial parks from the EIA Law would directly contradict Ukraine’s EU integration commitments, as the Verkhovna Rada’s EU integration committee also noted in its opinion on the bill.

Under the bill, an industrial park is an area equipped with relevant infrastructure where its participants conduct business. Equipping a park means work and services to prepare land plots and design, construct, reconstruct or repair engineering and transport infrastructure or other facilities needed for its operation. In the European Commission’s view, these are precisely the projects covered by point 10(a) of Annex II to the EIA Directive1. Moreover, these projects require not only EIA — both for the industrial park as a whole, as a separate activity, and for individual components if their activities fall under the EIA Law — but also, in many cases, SEA.

We also stress that in November 2024, the European Commission2 made clear that no additional derogations from SEA and EIA procedures in Ukraine were acceptable and that these procedures must apply to all plans, programmes and projects requiring them under EU legislation. Contrary to that position, attempts to narrow EIA, particularly during the war, are growing to an alarming scale. Adopting such changes moves us away from EU requirements. While the country works hard to complete accession negotiations at record speed, backsliding on commitments already fulfilled is simply unacceptable.

Civil society fully understands the need to create favourable conditions for national GDP growth. We nevertheless recall that reconstruction and further economic development must not cause significant harm to Ukraine’s environment. We therefore call for abandoning proposals to narrow the activities subject to EIA, including abolishing EIA for industrial parks, and for keeping such provisions out of Ukrainian bills and laws.

The letter is open for signatures.
Environment-People-Law
SaveDnipro
Bureau of Environmental Investigations
Ekoltava
National Ecological Centre of Ukraine
WWF-Ukraine
Greenpeace Ukraine; EcoClub
Save Pikui
Zero Waste Alliance Ukraine
Zero Waste Zaporizhzhia
Zero Waste Kharkiv
Zero Waste Ivano-Frankivsk
Zero Waste Mariupol
ANTS National Interests Advocacy Network
Stop Poisoning Kryvyi Rih
Osokorky Ecopark
Green Dossier Information Centre
Code 21
Ecosphere